Skip Navigation LinksHome > JCRC > Behind the Scenes - July 28, 2010
JCRC Logo

Behind the Scenes

From the Jewish Community Relations Council of Cincinnati July 28, 2010
Behind the Headlines
 
U.S.-Israel Relations 
 
Through advocacy with our local Members of Congress, the JCRC has been very active in enlisting Congressional support for policies that will advance the prospects for Middle East peace. Current priorities include pressing the Palestinian Authority (PA) to agree to direct negotiations with Israel, as well as implementation of recently enacted Iran sanctions legislation. Our meeting agendas have also included expressions of appreciation for our Members' support of Israel's right to self-defense in the wake of the Gaza Flotilla incident and the release of Gilad Shalit from captivity by Hamas, as well as their opposition to Iran's nuclear program and the international deligitimization of Israel.
 
Last week, U.S. envoy George Mitchell met with PA Authority President Mahmoud Abbas in an attempt to persuade Abbas to engage in direct negotiations with Israel. The U.S. supports Israel's willingness to engage in direct negotiations, as well as the measures Israel is offering in order to encourage direct talks. However, Abbas and the Fatah government continue to place preconditions on their willingness to participate, in particular insisting on a full settlement freeze by Israel before any such talks can begin. Mitchell continues to meet with representatives from the Arab states in order to secure support for these negotiations - this, too, is proving challenging.
 
On the Iran issue, international sanctions have already shown to impact the country's infrastructure, in particular its energy sector. The European Union has agreed to its own sanctions - the toughest yet to come out of Europe - to similarly target Iran's energy and financial sectors. We will continue to monitor and advocate for a full and speedy implementation of these sanctions.
 
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu met with President ObamaIsraeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu met with President Obama at the White House on July 6, in a much more positive visit than when the two leaders met last March. During the meeting, President Obama and PM Netanyahu saw eye to eye in their discussion of issues, including Gaza, Iran, nuclear weapons, and Middle East peace - agreeing that the time is right for direct negotiations to begin between the Palestinians and Israelis.
 
Following the meeting, President Obama expressed, "I believe that Prime Minister Netanyahu wants peace. I think he's willing to take risks for peace. And during our conversation, he once again reaffirmed his willingness to engage in serious negotiations with the Palestinians around what I think should be the goal not just of the two principals involved, but the entire world, and that is two states living side by side in peace and security... I believe that the government of Israel is prepared to engage in such direct talks, and I commend the Prime Minister for that."
 
A recent reporting of a public opinion poll conducted earlier this year revealed that U.S. support for Israel is near its record high. "The poll, conducted in early February, was part of Gallup's annual World Affairs survey in which Americans were asked a series of questions about their opinions of 20 countries or entities, including Israel and the Palestinian Authority. Israel's ranking, at 67 percent favorable, was among the highest of the countries surveyed."
 
Mainline Protestant Denominations Decline to Divest from Israel
 
In recent years, several Mainline Protestant denominations have begun considering proposals to divest from Israel, or from companies doing business with the Jewish State, at their national organizing conferences. The United Methodist Church (UMC) and Presbyterian Church USA (PC USA) are two of the denominations with whom the JCRC and others in the Jewish community have been in dialogue, and discussions this summer have resulted in two hopeful outcomes.
 
In Southwest Ohio, the United Methodist Church created a task force to study whether or not to divest investment funds from select companies operating in the disputed territories of the West Bank. The task force heard several perspectives, including the Cincinnati JCRC's, and as a result their material on Middle East issues is much more balanced and inclusive of both Israeli and Palestinian concerns. The task force concluded that while the divestment option would remain on the table for them, "other means, such as dialogue" are necessary first steps. We appreciate the partnership and openness expressed by members of the UMC task force.
 
The Presbyterian Church USA held its General Assembly at the beginning of July, a weeklong event that involved Jewish organizations such as the JCRC's national umbrella organization, the Jewish Council for Public Affairs, as well as the American Jewish Committee (AJC). The Jewish community was there to advocate in response to three problematic reports involving Israel - the Middle East Study Committee report that employed a highly selective use of facts and theology to delegitimize Israel, a proposal to withdraw the church's investments in the Caterpillar company for selling their building equipment to Israel, and an Interfaith Relations report about Christians and Jews.
 
As a result of this advocacy, which involved other Jewish organizations as well, PC USA adopted a more balanced policy on Middle East issues, and declined to adopt anti-Israel divestment or boycott policies. While the conversation will continue between the Presbyterian Church and the Jewish community, this allows for continued partnership on these issues. Local PC USA leaders - including Cincinnati General Presbytery Reverend Jim DiEgidio - have only been helpful to our community's concerns, and we owe a deep expression of gratitude to Barbara Glueck and our local AJC Chapter for their ongoing advocacy work with the local Presbyterian Church.
Israeli Conversion Bill
 
Last week, senior lay and professional leaders of the Cincinnati Jewish community participated in critical meetings with Israeli leaders that resulted in the tabling of a controversial proposed bill that would give the Chief Rabbinate of Israel unprecedented respon-sibility in the field of conversion. If this bill had become law, conversions to Judaism issued by rabbis associated with non-Orthodox move-ments, as well as by some Orthodox rabbis not approved by the Chief Rabbinate, would likely not be recognized as valid by the State. This would disproportionately impact those individuals moving to Israel from other countries, either those who have undergone non-Orthodox conversions through the Reform, Conservative or other movements, or those wanting to convert after arriving in Israel.
The coalition, led by the Jewish Federations of North America, successfully persuaded Prime Minister Netanyahu to oppose the Conversion Bill, as proposed in its current form by MK David Rotem. As a result, the Rotem Bill was removed from the docket for Knesset consideration before its three-month summer recess. In coordination with local rabbis and other community leaders, we will continue our efforts in the coming months to fully address this crucial issue in Israel-Diaspora relations.
 Check out the
new, revamped
David's Voice!

David's Voice

David's Voice is an electronic magazine geared towards the young and young-at-heart Jews of Cincinnati. It aims to be the platform to share, experience, and interact with cutting edge and positive people and happenings in the Cincinnati Jewish community.
Join Our Mailing List
 
Quick Links
 
Jewish Community Relations Council of the Jewish Federation of Cincinnati  
                 Gary Greenberg, President                 Brian Jaffee, Director 
                 Jessica Baron, Vice President           Gal Adam Spinrad, Associate Director 
                 Steve Shifman, Vice President
Safe Unsubscribe
This email was sent to szimmerman@jfedcin.org by bjaffee@jfedcin.org.
Jewish Community Relations Council of the Jewish Federation of Cincinnati | 8499 Ridge Road | Cincinnati | OH | 45236